Nicoletta Pizzeria Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Nicoletta Pizzeria, a delightful dining establishment located at 107 Morristown Rd, Bernardsville, NJ. Known for its warm atmosphere and exceptional service, Nicoletta offers a menu that celebrates the art of pizza-making.
Start with enticing appetizers like the Polpettine, featuring prosciutto & mortadella meatballs served with a rich pomodoro sauce, or indulge in their signature Calabrian Chili Wings for a spicy kick. The pizzas shine with options like the Calabrese for meat lovers and the creamy Tartufata for fans of white-based pies, each crafted with fresh, homemade toppings.
Don’t forget to top off your meal with their heavenly Bomboloni, these citrusscented ricotta doughnuts will tantalize your taste buds. With a selection of handcrafted drinks and an inviting ambiance, Nicoletta Pizzeria is truly a gem worth visiting. Come discover why customers rave about their exceptional culinary experiences!
APPS
Mista
bibb lettuce, apple, carrots, beets, fennel, champagne vinaigrette
Romana
romaine lettuce, anchovy vinaigrette, parmigiano, garlic breadcrumb
Chopped
romaine, radicchio, pepperoni, prosciutto cotto, olives chickpeas provolone, red peppers, herbed vinaigrette ADD SHRIMP 9 ADD CALAMARI 8 ADD BREADED CHICKEN 8 ADD GRILLED CHICKEN 7
Polpettine
prosciutto & mortadella meatballs, pomodoro, ricotta grilled bread
Calabrian Chili Wings
8 wings, Calabrian chili glaze, blue cheese
Mozzarella Fritti
sundried tomato argodolce
Arancini
bolognese stuffed risotto croquettes
Garlic Knots
garlic & basil 3 6 / 6 10, truffle roasted garlic 3 7 / 6 12
Spaghetti Pomodoro
Rigatoni Vodka
spinach, parmigiano, pepperoni
Gramigna
sausage ragu, black pepper, whipped ricotta
PASTA
SANDWICHES
Parmigiana
breaded chicken, pomodoro, mozzarella, provolone, garlic butter
Tacchino
thinly sliced turkey, sundried tomato spread, fresh mozzarella, caramelized fennel, arugula
Meatball Sub
fontina cheese, pomodoro, basil-pine nut pesto
Italian Sub
prosciutto, mortadella, salami picante, capocollo, provolone, cherry peppers, roasted cherry tomatoes, red peppers, arugula, herb vinaigrette
Roast Pork Sub
broccoli rabe, roasted long hots, provolone
Nicoletta Burger
house blend, fileto di pomodoro, scamorza, salami picante, saffron aioli
Bomboloni
citrus-scented ricotta doughnuts salted caramel sauce, dark chocolate sauce
Crostata
fried cinnamon apple hand pies caramel sauce, vanilla whipped cream
DESSERT
PIZZAS
Classica
mozzarella, pomodoro, parmigiano, basil
Bianca
white sauce, 4 cheese
Calabrese
pepperoni, fennel sausage, red onions
Tartufata
prosciutto cotto, mushroom, truffle cream
Funghi
mushrooms, sauteed spinach, marsala
Sausage and Peppers
fennel sausage, braised peppers & onions oregano
Italian Buffalo Chicken
crispy chicken, bacon, gorgonzola
Margherita
jersey tomato pomodoro, fresh local mozzarella, basil
Bolognese
mozzarella, robiolina, classic meat ragu
Chef's Pizza Pick
white pie, truffle and red onion confiture, mortadella, fried sage
CHEF'S PIZZA PICK
DRINKS
Regular Soda
Wild Bills Soda
root beer • birch beer • dr bills • blackberry strawberry cream • orange cream
Stella Artois
Beer
Goose Island IPA
Beer
Hoegaarden Witbier
Beer
Menabrea Ambrata
Beer
Longboard Lager
Beer
House White - Gavi di Gavi
Wines BTG
Sauvignon Blanc
Wines BTG
House Red - Primitivo
Wines BTG
Montepulciano
Wines BTG